Yes, but is Bardock a brilliant scientist?
It just makes it very generic and lame IMO the thing that seperated Goku's backstory from Superman's was that Goku was sent to take over earth and ironically ended up becoming a savior, in contrast of this Namekians were actually a peaceful race and Piccolo turned out to be the exception. Unlike Superman, Goku does not give a damn about his heritage or parents, he was glad that most saiyans were dead because they were evil.Ultimately the addition in Minus and the retcon of his age makes his past more tragic,
Gohan already mentioned how goku was a savage before hitting his head so he would've grown up to be an anti-hero or even a villian with a much more meaner personality like Vegeta's.so we don't truly know for certain what he could have become if he had "his original personality"
Piccolo turned out to be the exception because Kami specifically expelled what evil he had in his heart to become Guardian of Earth and the evil remains became King Piccolo and eventually Piccolo Jr. You can at least try to be honest about his backstory.It just makes it very generic and lame IMO the thing that seperated Goku's backstory from Superman's was that Goku was sent to take over earth and ironically ended up becoming a savior, in contrast of this Namekians were actually a peaceful race and Piccolo turned out to be the exception. Unlike Superman, Goku does not give a damn about his heritage or parents, he was glad that most saiyans were dead because they were evil.
Which is another problem i have with DB:Minus, it portrays Bardock&Gine like this nice loving human couple who are just misunderstood or something and not the planet conquering warrior race they are. FoG special did this perfectly, it showed saiyans as uncaring, ruthless bastards. One thing that should always be established is that Bardock is NOT a good guy, he's still killing more people than hitler on a daily basis. Making him look like this super nice guy just defeats the purpose of it or rather sugarcoats that part of Bardock. Keep in mind, i'm only going by FoG as a reference, considering how its non-canon all we know of bardock&gine canonically is that they were very good people who did nothing wrong.
Gohan already mentioned how goku was a savage before hitting his head so he would've grown up to be an anti-hero or even a villian with a much more meaner personality like Vegeta's.
Those people are completely ignoring that A) Toriyama had shown a brief flashback of Bardock's rebellion in the manga thus it was always canon and B) Minus leaves plenty of room for Bardock to attempt his rebellion as seen in said flashback.The DB forums are riddled with "Because of DB Minus Bardock won't rebel like he did in Bardock FoG. I will cut my wrists now."
Fear not, Chibi Raditz will appear (unless they leave out/change his scene with Chibi Vegeta). :wink:The REAL real issue is, where's my boy Raditz at!? And will we see Beerus authorizing the destruction of Planet Vegeta? Actually, more important than those, is will we see baby Tarble?
I dunno where this trend of "Minus makes Bardock a wimp!" comes from. The first page of Minus literally starts with the narration ""The Saiyan warrior race - under Emperor Freeza's orders have been fighting day and night to conquer planets for their evil lord." And we see Bardock and his squad killing the local inhabitants of an unnamed planet - he definitely ain't no saint. The reason it only gets a single page dedicated is that we KNOW all this from the main series and it would be pointless to retread old ground. Plus, is Bardock not allowed to love another person when he's not being a warrior? He's not a total sociopath, hell even Freeza and King Cold show some level of familial affection for each other.Which is another problem i have with DB:Minus, it portrays Bardock&Gine like this nice loving human couple who are just misunderstood or something and not the planet conquering warrior race they are. FoG special did this perfectly, it showed saiyans as uncaring, ruthless bastards. One thing that should always be established is that Bardock is NOT a good guy, he's still killing more people than hitler on a daily basis. Making him look like this super nice guy just defeats the purpose of it or rather sugarcoats that part of Bardock. Keep in mind, i'm only going by FoG as a reference, considering how its non-canon all we know of bardock&gine canonically is that they were very good people who did nothing wrong.
I dunno man, if I were a toddler and I was sent to an unknown planet I wouldn't exactly be friendly to a complete stranger who tried to take me away. Goku acting hostile makes sense to me IMO.Gohan already mentioned how goku was a savage before hitting his head so he would've grown up to be an anti-hero or even a villian with a much more meaner personality like Vegeta's.
Notice I'm not calling this "intellectual dishonesty" because such a term presumes intellect on your end and I'm not seeing it.
Are you... are you high right now dude?
Come back when you have a functioning brain, and no sooner.
Source your claim or go away.
I was talking about the ENTIRE Namekian race as how they were portrayed in Namek Saga, it was shown that not all Namekians were evil but only the evil half of Kami.You can at least try to be honest about his backstory.
And i was gonna call you "rude", but that would assume you're capable of being anything other than a condescending asshole. **** your arguments and everything else you have to say, if you're just gonna start with a personal insult OVER a ****ing cartoon then i'm not going to humour your retarded posts!Notice I'm not calling this "intellectual dishonesty" because such a term presumes intellect on your end and I'm not seeing it.
@ROCKMAN X
You know those "snowflake" types that whine when some fictional media isn't catering exactly to them and when someone actually brings up a halfway decent and logical argument for why they're wrong, they go into hysterics and latch on to the part where their feelings got hurt and then also "stoop" to slurs and insults?
That's you, dude.
I was talking about the ENTIRE Namekian race as how they were portrayed in Namek Saga, it was shown that not all Namekians were evil but only the evil half of Kami.
And i was gonna call you "rude", but that would assume you're capable of being anything other than a condescending asshole. **** your arguments and everything else you have to say, if you're just gonna start with a personal insult OVER a ****ing cartoon then i'm not going to humour your retarded posts!
True. I've deleted the offending comments from the long post.This is meant to be a discussion, not an argument and was no need for the personal insults to present your point. Same as he shouldn’t have retaliated with words of a similar manner as just ends up going backwards and forwards and people ignore your points when you have hostile tone.
True. I've deleted the offending comments from the long post.
I think we can have a discussion as long as people don't resort to alarmist nonsense and "ruined forever" claims off of a grand total of two trailers just because they don't like something the creator did.... when the creator's been doing umping to conclusions on a media they haven't even read fully.
I don't need to "respect" the dislike in the least bit, because it is still alarmist nonsense from fanboys clinging to a barely-canon appearance of a secondary character from 20 years past that the original creator had no part in aside from acknowledging in two panels. The assumption of his badassery comes from his costume design and his limited dialogue even though he ultimately went out in a completely pathetic way, fodderized by a blast that wasn't meant for him specifically. Bardock is the Boba Fett of Dragonball.
I watch Geekdom. You think anyone that watches him has to kiss his ass on everything he says? Why can't you formulate your own points well enough without some Big Name Fan's help?
Here's a better question: why are you whining about "stifling discussion" here? What discussion are YOU fostering, when all you do is complain about the problems you have with a media that isn't even out yet? You don't want to have your points disagreed with or engage in anything, you just want people to mindlessly agree that "Bardock sucks now and Goku is a ripoff of Superman" when they're still not the focal point of this movie. It's about BROLY.
@Lain made a perfectly good point above on how the complaints of "Bardock is a wimp" are baseless because he's still out conquering planets, he's simply a bit more three-dimensional, and care for his own family (like he cared for his friends/his race in the original media) doesn't make him any less ruthless toward his enemies. Even King Cold cares for Freeza.
But oh look, you and Rockman both skipped RIGHT OVER THAT.
You're not looking for any civil discussion, you just wanna vomit useless complaints about a secondary character's backstory being changed in a feature film where a secondary character's backstory is getting changed, and then defer to a Big Name Fan's argument (or in Rockman's case, throw a tantrum) when things don't go your way. You can hop right off to Kanzenshuu, I'm sure they'll love you there.
I don't need to "respect" the dislike in the least bit, because it is still alarmist nonsense from fanboys
Why can't you formulate your own points well enough without some Big Name Fan's help?
Here's a better question: why are you whining about "stifling discussion" here? What discussion are YOU fostering, when all you do is complain about the problems you have with a media that isn't even out yet? You don't want to have your points disagreed with or engage in anything, you just want people to mindlessly agree that "Bardock sucks now and Goku is a ripoff of Superman" when they're still not the focal point of this movie. It's about BROLY.
You're not looking for any civil discussion, you just wanna vomit useless complaints about a secondary character's backstory being changed in a feature film where a secondary character's backstory is getting changed, and then defer to a Big Name Fan's argument (or in Rockman's case, throw a tantrum) when things don't go your way. You can hop right off to Kanzenshuu, I'm sure they'll love you there.
there is legit no disputing it since even the the most casual fan of the two series can see this,
@Morgan "you bringing up the question [...] just comes across as you "reaching" to illustrate some kind of point to discredit my own when really it does not work [...] there legit is no disputing that clear fact as hard as you may try.
[...]
let me once again reiterate my main point here and I'm going to put it in bold [...]
But whatever, you appear to be ok with this change and origin [...] I'll just agree to disagree and move on from this discussion since there is nothing you can say to change my opinion on the matter and vice versa.