The problem with Roshi matching Jiren was twofold:
1. Even if Jiren was holding back, he could hold back on his strength while still being faster than Roshi can even conceptualize. That shouldn't even be a problem for him. He's way stronger than Roshi to the point he shouldn't need to block any of Roshi's hits as opposed to tanking them and letting Roshi break his own fists. He also can't be so slow that he can allow himself to actually be frustrated that Roshi can dodge. Roshi couldn't even see Frost moving nor Base Goku moving in this tournament. That was all in-panel done by Toyotaro. Now all the sudden, it doesn't matter anymore.
We've seen powerful characters throughout DBZ one-shot characters way weaker than them without killing them, while also doing it nigh-instantly. Cell kicked Krillin through a mountain and slapped Mr. Satan into another mountain. Kid Trunks punched Mr. Satan and that dude still ain't dead yet. Goku neck-chopped Chi-Chi into a tree once and she isn't dead. Beerus beat up all the Z-fighters during Bulma's party. So it doesn't make any sense that Jiren, who is more powerful than his own God of Destruction and undeniably faster than Roshi, who took out an intergalactic criminal non-lethally via flying into them at a high-speed from space Superman-style, who's fodderized opponents in a single hit throughout this tournament and took out Hit with an uppercut, who beat
time itself, is somehow both too slow and too incompetent to just.......... beat Roshi instantly like he did
every single other opponent he was shown doing it to. Why is Roshi able to dodge Jiren at all when Jiren could just make himself go faster literally any time he wanted to? Roshi didn't need to fight Jiren for this. He could have shown his instinctive dodging technique against Kahseral, or even Dyspo.
2. Toyotaro somehow forgets that Goku is still the same "fighting genius" that resolved to perfect the first Super Saiyan form instead of jumping to Ultra Super Saiyan whatever forms because he realized their limitations and didn't want to sacrifice speed for power. He mastered the first form to conserve stamina and maximize its output. He not only learned that lesson, he
taught the lesson to others
. Here, Goku turns into an absolute meathead that tries to copy Kale, screaming about needing
"more power!!!!!" and not caring about destroying his own body to do it, when he just saw Kale try that and fail, and he realized that himself back in DBZ when training for the Cell Games. So basically he regressed into the same thing Future Trunks did against Perfect Cell, somehow. He's smarter than that. And we also saw Goku almost ring-out Jiren in the anime using some well-placed ki mines, knowledge of his terrain, and a Kienzan. People that kept up with anime!DBS know what a reasonably smart Goku should act and sound like. So he's not a bad fighter or strategist when someone actually cares enough to write him properly.
Roshi
himself decided he couldn't train Goku any more and told him to go off on his own and train under others who he could learn from. Goku can't all of a sudden be a bad student now of all times. And what was the point of him training with Whis this whole time if his answer to being beaten is "destroy my own body with quasi-Kaioken", when Whis was trying to teach him exactly the part about Ultra Instinct? Yeah, we've seen Goku use Kaioken to increase his power and speed at the cost of his own body before, but very famously with Hit and the SSB+KK combination, he did it to get an edge on an opponent he figured out after watching for a few seconds. Goku breaking through the improved Timeskip and being able to predict Hit's attacks by the way he moved
was genius. What was
this in comparison? Him needing to watch Roshi dodge moves instinctively to learn how to do the same, when
Beerus was doing the same thing to 12 Gods at once in the tournament that happened just before this one? If all he needed to do was watch someone dodge and think on stuff a bit, he should've
been learned Ultra Instinct.
This chapter achieves a level of OOC for Goku that even people who hated Dragonball GT and the Funimation dubs noticed.
Actually let me add a third point:
3. Right afterward, Jiren takes a complete (verbal) dump on Goku's fighting skill. At least in the anime he recognized Goku as a warrior, even if a weak one, and acknowledged him as a threat to Toppo. Here in the manga, he doubts Goku can even fight
at all. Goku's a total scrub to him. Yikes on bikes!
Now................................
Don't get me started on Gohan matching Kefla when:
LSSJ Kale knocked out four universes in under ten panels of one chapter
on her own, one-shotted Anilaza, caught Golden Frieza off guard and forced Goku to go Blue to defend himself from her, as well as almost knocked out Vegeta and Toppo in one hit. LSSJ Kale was so powerful that her
own power was kicking her ass. Then LSSJ Kale fuses with Caulifla. Vados says that Kefla is Kale's LSSJ power, that excess energy that Kale has, but with Caulifla's intelligence and control, making her the ultimate warrior unmatched in the battlefield. The Pride Troopers that ganged up on Kale got fodderized by the fusion and even Kahseral said Kefla was leagues above regular Kale. Yet Kefla somehow loses to..... Gohan.
A Gohan who wasn't even in his Ultimate form when he beat her.
A Gohan who still isn't on Goku's level.
A Gohan who is weaker than his anime counterpart by scaling alone (Anime BoG arc has Goku absorbing the God Ki into his base form and everyone else is scaled in relation to that, Manga BoG arc does not have Goku absorbing the Ki, and every other character scales accordingly).
A Gohan who obviously probably cannot one-shot Anilaza by himself.
A Gohan who only started training after the defeat of Merged Zamazu, meanwhile Anime Gohan was already training since just after Frieza was defeated, and during the Goku Black arc he said his goodbye to Trunks
directly after a training session with Piccolo was already underway. Meaning he trained for less time in the manga than the anime along with being weaker in the manga than the anime.
A Gohan who Beerus doesn't even bother to learn the name of, calling him "Spawn of Son Goku".
This Gohan.
This Gohan gets eliminated in a battle that's mostly offscreen after a tease and maybe a few punches and some dialogue, whereas the anime had him saving Piccolo the same way Piccolo saved him, and making a big deal out of their mentor-student relationship. Anime Gohan contributed to some universes being eliminated, reflected on what he was fighting for in terms of his family being safe, and went out by a double-KO against the #3 fighter in Universe 11, the universe with the most powerful opponents.
Manga Gohan's proof of power is...... uhhhhhhhhhhhh.... despite his apparent super duper power, that could have made him an asset to universe 7, he gets knocked out in ONE FIGHT against a heavily-nerfed Potara fusion from the third-most powerful universe, showing no growth as a character in terms of his relationship to Piccolo because Piccolo was already knocked out by a trash-tier bug early on in the tourney. The only "decent" thing about Manga Gohan is the change in his personality to his Buu Saga arrogance, as if anyone actually liked that about him since he absolutely acted like a dumbass in the Buu Saga. And that "I chose to evolve as a human" nonsense, like he didn't get to where he is by winning the genetic lottery in terms of his Saiyan genes mixing perfectly with his human ones to account for all his power boosts. Otherwise, he was a complete idiot. He could have just, you know, LET Kefla fight Jiren, let her lose utterly to Jiren, and then focused his efforts on Dyspo and other opponents.
And to top this off, Kefla is defeated after giving some speech that amounts to verbal fellatio towards U7's fighters, where she calls herself a loser and then agrees to basically commit suicide, which is completely unbecoming of a Saiyan and OOC to either Kefla or either of the Saiyans that comprised her. She accepted defeat with some straight-up fanfiction-tier writing that didn't need to be written at all. Meanwhile the anime showed Kefla's incredulity in the face of potential defeat and her response was balls-to-the-wall attacks while she ramped up her power, determined to "outsmart" UI dodges with her spur-of-the-moment omnidirectional Ki beams that actually tagged Goku at one point or two, so well that
he had to outthink his limitations in order to beat her. Manga Kefla does no Ki attacks. Just punches and then says it was "fate"/"destiny" that she lost to some dude.
Then Champa doesn't have a touching moment with Beerus, instead going into a spiel about how "this doesn't change anything!" as if he already knows he's getting wished back in the end and they can continue their rivalry later.
F**k that.
At least when the anime ignored "power scaling" and "power levels" and all that (doing the same "power levels don't matter" thing that people are now praising the manga for doing?????), we got good character moments. We got Roshi outsmarting demons with Mafuba, delivering a speech to
both of his students and not just Goku, and going out like an OG on his own terms, eliminating himself instead of becoming a liability for his team. We got Piccolo realizing the resolve of all the Namekians in a counterpart universe and reinforcing his own bond with Nail and Kami. We got 18 showing she cared about Krillin and doing the "sappy human stuff" for 17's sake. Even Tien had a better showing in the anime than he did in the manga, and he absolutely sucked in the anime.
I can't even with this.