God only knows my despise towards this modern trend of ranking everything, from the food we eat to the quality of the dump we take in the morning when we expel it, so I'm not gonna "rank" the Dante's (I don't know how it makes any sense, really, "ranking" a character, like, wut). Rather, I'ma just list them from fav to least fav, explaining why. So for those who like scores, you can still have an idea of how my scores would be.
Devil May Cry 3: Dante's Awakening
As berto said in an older thread very similar to this one, here is when the character's at his most complex. Has got some development (which the other games in the original series don't really provide for him), as we see him gradually change throughout the game and become more similar to how he is in the first game - still fun loving, yet more aware of himself. Plus, the way he interacts with the bosses here and screws around with them, Vergil included, is the best. Easily among the most memorable things in the series, the boss encounters.
Devil May Cry
The original one, despite not having much going on for him in terms of development (he's pretty much the same guy by the end of the game), throughout the game we get to see what the aspects of his personality are, and overall he's the most likeable. However his lines lack impact in most cases and the quality of the voice acting (a problem of the whole game, to be fair), notoriously bad, doesn't help.
Devil May Cry 4
This guy has very little going on for his character, unlike the cases above, but as I see it, it's something it can be overlooked because he's no more than a side character in this game, in a story that is not his. The redeeming qualities are that he's hella entertaining and he's got some major badass moments going throughout the game. Also, he probably looks more intimidating here, despite his attitude, than he ever has in any game of the series.
DmC: Devil May Cry
Yeah I chose a pic with the Neo costume cause it's my favorite, get over it.
Now, I'm not a huge fan of this iteration, despite undeniably having development as a character (and that's really his redeeming quality here), for two reasons, mainly. One, I find his personality pretty obnoxious, a sentiment exacerbated by the fact that the setting he's in is a little more grounded, and grittier, and he seems to clash with it on the whole. Which brings me to reason number two, I'm pretty sure that Ninja Theory had something very different in mind for this guy. As the 2010 trailer for DmC heavily seems to suggest, this Dante should have been a way broodier, edgier version of what we got, which would have made a lot more sense given his background story. But we all know the drill, fans backlashed worse than a Xenomorph who's got its tail stomped on, and the team ended up going out of their way to give him some traits of the older Dante's personalities, and the often cheap "sex, alcohol and thug life" gimmick to try and make it look cool to the eyes of the players.
Devil May Cry: The Animated Series
Dull, bored and boring, easily the biggest shift from anything he's supposed to be (if not for the obvious - at this point - last place), very little going on for his character, and he doesn't even "get a pass" like DMC4 Dante, cause here, he IS the main guy and he's not even all that entertaining. The only thing that keeps him from being the last on my list is that sometimes here and there, there is something that has to deals with his character in the series, and a couple of action scenes are badass. There, not much else to say.
Devil May Cry 2
Yes he looks ****ing badass. But holy God does he come across as even more boring than his anime counterpart. He barely even talks. Dante, the demon hunter who likes to taunt and talk **** about demonkind, here barely talks. A couple of cool shots and one memorable line is all I could get from this guy, really. He felt just there. Like, whatever. And such a sentiment, as I see it, is even worse than the most passionate of hate, cause at the very least, if you hate a character, it means it does have
something that makes you hate it. This guy just spawned indifference in me. I can barely talk about him, he's so shallow. In fact I feel like I'm going in circles repeating pretty much the same thing, that he's boring, so there, I'll just stop.