CoolDemon, this was exactly what the mod '
Tony_Redgrave' mentioned after closing the Screamo thread...
You have already mentioned all of this several times now. We get it! It is time to move on...
Anyways, on topic. I don't think Capcom/Ninja Theory exactly knows what DmC is compared to the original series, hence the confusion on what to call it. Is it a reboot? An alternate universe? A different take on DMC? Or maybe all of them?
I see it like this... It
IS the same Dante, however, it is his story retold through other glasses. Like a legend or mythos retold throughout different parts of the world. E.g. let's take Zeus as an example. He is the king of all the gods of Olympus in ancient Greek mythology. In Norse mythology, the king of all the gods is called Odin and his realm is called Asgard. After much research, experts have come to the conclusion that they are basically the same god, but told by different nations with their different takes on it, and that the stories are based from the same origin.
It's the same with Dante. No, the world is not exactly like we know it from the original series, and no, Dante doesn't look like the original Dante, and he even has another origin story... But they are, none the less, based on the same character, the same mythos, just told differently by different people. It is a new interpretation of Devil May Cry and Dante's adventures.
And THAT is why the two Dantes are compared like they are. Because basically, they are the same character.
I know, it's a twisted way of seeing it and can be hard to understand, especially if you choose not to believe it, but that's how I see it anyways.