same guy, doesn't really matter...no matter how many parallel universes there are, Peter Parker is still Peter Parker, and Dante is Dante...it's the same fricken guy...claiming anything else is just ignorance to fact.
Comics are a different media. And just because you and other comic readers have accepted many different Peter Parkers as the exact same Peter Parker it does not apply to games or people's perceptions.
Let me break down your argument:
Mario throughout the years is Mario. Even if the story is different, the character that is Mario has been preserved. If you look at 1985 Mario and 2006 Mario you will say "Hey, it's the same guy". Sure Mario was a carpenter in beginning, but profession change is a natural thing. Mario can be both carpenter and plummer. There is no law saying "Mario you can only work as one profession only!". Think about it - is it that unlogical for Mario to be able to have two professions? No.
Bottomline: He stayed the same Mario from 1985 to 2006. And Dante from DMC 2, 3 and 4 are all accepted as Dante by fans because of one simple reason: They stayed true to Dante's character.
The things that is very important by Dante's character is:
1) His hair is white because he was born with it.
2) He is half human and half demon
3) He jokes around and isn't the kind of guy who takes situation with a grim face.
Red jacket that Dante has is not a important thing by his character. Because it's just a cloth, it's not something that makes Dante who he is.
Ninja theory's Dante :
1) is half angel and half demon
2) Has white hair supposedly because of demon powers /or no white hair at all.
In a reboot sense a character can stay the same for people to be able to call them the same. Take Parasite Eve reboot (Third Birthday) or Tombraider reboot:
Both of those characters are very much the same as the original characters.
Aya Brea (Parasite Eve)
Original
REBOOT
TOMB RAIDER:
Original:
REBOOT:
Reboot characters that preserve original characters' character deserved to be called the same as the original. Because they are pretty much the same.
But this NT' Dante is just a new character that uses Dante's character for ideas, and DmC is called a "parallel universe" to calm down people, and as a excuse to make a new character.
If NT' Dante is in a parallel universe, and because he is in a parallel universe he is the same character As DMC Dante, then who are these characters (These are in two other parallel universes)?:
1:43
People who accept many characters as the same can't let go of something they like. You should have respect for a character and let go when it's time is over.
And then in DmC controversy there are people who like NT's Dante and bash DMC Dante and promote DmC Dante.
I could make my own Dante. Fan fiction is what it's called, but when it's put forward as offical it's no longer fan fiction. Making my own Dante is the greatest way for me (a Dante fan) to disrespect Dante. I don't need to do that , Dante is cool and i don't need to see him be anyone else than who he is.
Sure Dante needs development but he doesn't need stupid changes. Stupid changes are made by people who want a character to be in their liking. If you don't like a character then leave.
I guess i am ignorant because i don't see NT's Dante and DMC Dante as the same, even in a reboot sense they are not.