So ****ing sick of book reviewers on Amazon thinking they know how to give proper reviews.
I don't care if their review is harsh, if they give fewer stars than other people. I do care, however, when the basis for such a low rating is something as asinine as, "I didn't like half of the characters, and the one I really liked died" (lack of spoiler warning as they go further on about how), along with a header that says "Amazing plot". So, let me get this straight: you thought the plot was amazing, but you gave it a one-star...
Over one. ****ing. Character?
And then you have the people who say, "I thought I knew how it would end, and frankly the ending I had in mind is better and makes more sense." You presumptuous little ****. Don't you dare think you know better than the author how her characters should think, feel, act, etc. Don't you dare presume to think you could have done better, because I promise you, you couldn't. They are not your characters; this is not your world, or your book series--so shove off.
Please, by all means, do try. Try to write a layered plot with complex characters, woven from the fibres of both fantasy and reality. You're the type of person that makes the vindictive side of me come to life; the side that would enjoy watching someone try and fail, because that person dared to think they had any claim as to how things played out in someone else's world.
It's one thing to say you find it dissatisfying because you were hoping for it to end different. It is quite another to assume you could do better than the creator.
I don't care if their review is harsh, if they give fewer stars than other people. I do care, however, when the basis for such a low rating is something as asinine as, "I didn't like half of the characters, and the one I really liked died" (lack of spoiler warning as they go further on about how), along with a header that says "Amazing plot". So, let me get this straight: you thought the plot was amazing, but you gave it a one-star...
Over one. ****ing. Character?
And then you have the people who say, "I thought I knew how it would end, and frankly the ending I had in mind is better and makes more sense." You presumptuous little ****. Don't you dare think you know better than the author how her characters should think, feel, act, etc. Don't you dare presume to think you could have done better, because I promise you, you couldn't. They are not your characters; this is not your world, or your book series--so shove off.
Please, by all means, do try. Try to write a layered plot with complex characters, woven from the fibres of both fantasy and reality. You're the type of person that makes the vindictive side of me come to life; the side that would enjoy watching someone try and fail, because that person dared to think they had any claim as to how things played out in someone else's world.
It's one thing to say you find it dissatisfying because you were hoping for it to end different. It is quite another to assume you could do better than the creator.
Last edited: