Where's your proof that that's true?
For them to still have JC, Weapon switching, fluid gameplay, an actual good DMC story, Vergil pretty much untouched in appearence, Mundus back, Dante still cocky, stronger demons, Mundus returning, the world shifting, and the two brothers reunite to kick Mundus's ass, paying homage to both DMC1 and DMC3?
I'd say that's caring for your old fanbase.
The only reason some disagree is because a western development is handling it, and Dante doesn't look the same as before.
Simple, Capcom had alot to prove yes, but there was an easy way out of this, that would please the fanbase, THAT CAPCOM HAD ALREADY DONE!
Because if they TRULY cared about the original fanbase, they would go both ways by announcing the following.
"After the game is finished. We are making 'DmC: Off the Record', in which you play as Original Dante in the DmC setting.
The game will have the style system from the original 4 games, along with some help from Platinum Games for gameplay innovations. Ninja Theory will return as writers, trying to keep Dante a mix between DMC1 and DMC3 attitude wise, and suit wise, he will be wearing something similar to his DMC1 attire. The story should be as good, if not better, than DmC. Since we've made most of the enviroments, concepts, and such for DmC, Off the Record should only take 2 years at most, and should be great."
I mean really, they did this EXACT SAME THING with Dead Rising, why not DmC?
It would be easy, it would put a crap load of money in Capcoms pocket, and it would be fun for fans of the original series like me.
EVERYONE FREAKING WINS!
So why did Capcom not think of doing this?
Because
Either
A. They were stupid and were banging their own keyboards against their heads.
B. They are planning on something like this, but just haven't announced it yet.
C. Capcom don't care about the original fanbase.
I don't care how stupid people think it is, CAPCOM HAS DONE IT BEFORE!
Capcom could easily do this game, and yet they choose not to. It's ridiculous.