DmC is slower by a somewhat small margin, but I don't really think it's clunky at all. Clunky means like...what? Not being able to do things when you want to do them? And controls being too complicated for simple actions, like if to jump in Mario you had to be running, hold up on the D-Pad, and press B, right? I don't think DmC falls under the clunky category at all.
One thing about DmC is that while it has similar controls and actions to classic DMCs, it still controls its own way. Chaser, I know you aren't much of a fan of the buffering windows the game has, but...looking at it objectively, it still works doesn't it? For an action game, DmC is still pretty good, right? It's not DMC3 or 4 caliber, but I still think it's sits with them. This game has its own things that it's doing, and I think it does them alright, and as a game that's supposed to help pull more people into DMC as a whole, I'd think this works a helluva lot better than Easy Automatic. I agree with you on that mode, it does little to actually encourage the player to get better :/
Claims of "evolved combat" by PR and whatnot I never really listened to, but hey...evolution doesn't always mean exactly better, just...emphasizing a specific aspect sometimes. DmC emphasizes accessibility, and I will definitely agree that it does make things more accessible, through its control scheme or its greater difficulty range. For the game they wanted to make, I'd say they achieved it. Alienated fans be damned, that's their own prerogative to feel that way.
For what it's worth, perceived problems and all, I'm still all for this game. I don't give a damn whether it's "too easy" or whatever compared to the classic DMCs, people can compare it all they want, but...Capcom wanted to do something different, and I accept that. I wasn't expecting this to be a carbon copy of the classics with a new skin. I knew what I was getting into, and I don't regret it.
And Alchemist, for the love of gunblades, dial it back about ten notches. It's great that you love the game, that's awesome, but don't be an extremist, it doesn't help anyone, and it just makes you seem extremely standoffish. And in public fora, the last thing you want in a civil discussion is someone you don't think you can have a civil discussion with.