• Welcome to the Devil May Cry Community Forum!

    We're a group of fans who are passionate about the Devil May Cry series and video gaming.

    Register Log in

What was Vergil's real story?

Dante's Stalker

"Outrun this!"
Premium
Supporter 2014
I debated about where to put this, but since Nero is going to be mentioned I figured DMC4 board would be most suited.

So, this is the old discussion about why Vergil had gone on his mission to gain Sparda's power. I know a lot of people say that 1 - he wanted more power to protect his loved ones, and 2 - that the loss of his mother was his motivation for obtaining power.

Here I come with my fiery poker to burn that theory down.

1. Why would he go out of his way for power to protect his loved ones if the only family he has left is Dante? Nobody has ever really explored this idea and everyone seems happy to settle for half-hearted answers.

He activated Dante's DT, which Dante probably was completely unaware of existed up to that point, because he knew it would aid in making Dante near indestructible and enable him to protect himself. So, with that done and dusted, he still continued on with his plan to get more power. Why? Most fans seem to be in agreement that Vergil had merely become misguided and corrupt, that he was a good guy with good intentions but his ruthlessness at living up to his aspirations made him the 'bad' guy.

Another idea that sprouts from Vergil's obsession to become more powerful is because he wants to follow in Sparda's footsteps. But why would he want that? Family tradition for the eldest son to step in his father's shoes? Not a chance. Both boys are quite indifferent to Sparda as their father-figure, which makes 'family tradition' a very lame reason with no substance.

2. Again, this rings true to me but it hasn't been deliberated on. Of course losing his mother would be enough motivation, but exactly what was his goal to obtain that power? He can't protect her, she's already dead. He can't bring her back to life, either. Yet this idea always goes in hand with the first theory. Vergil wanted more power. What motivated him? His mother's death. Why did he want it? To protect his loved ones.

First off, my explanation for getting to the theory that I have is that in every game a certain quality of Sparda is made prominent in the 'important' characters, and because of that in a way history repeats itself.

In DMC1, Dante had to face basically losing his family all over again and then still have the strength to finish off Mundus. Who's to say that Sparda wasn't on his way to stop Mundus from hurting his family when the attack on his family actually took place? I'm pretty sure Sparda wasn't dead up until that event took place, and he had to have had good reason not to be there for his family when they needed him most. Anyway, point: Dante was emotionally tormented and had to fight off Mundus. Sparda had to do the same when he sealed away Mundus, and if he had the heart to love a human being, and still acknowledged his true origins, it couldn't have been that easy for him to betray his own kind.

Okay, DMC2 - Dante had to go to hell to finish off the bad guy. Plenty of references made about him saving the world and being like Sparda, so that in itself speaks for itself.

DMC3 - Vergil sets out to follow his aspirations, which is to become like Sparda.

DMC4 - Nero and Kyrie - love, mushy fluffiness, demon + mortal = :wub: You get the idea.

So, here's my theory about Vergil. And yes, you may hate me for it, but flame Capcom because I'm confident that I've either got the plot figured out or I'm pretty damn close to the real thing. And plotting is my expertise, so don't discredit me just because you don't like what I've come up with, cos all I've done is picked up the threads Capcom left floating around and tied them all up.

Vergil's motivation to become like Sparda was not to physically follow in his father's steps, and his hunger and need for more power wasn't because he'd been manipulated by the demonic forces and adopted their ways. If that was the case, he wouldn't have lived in a mansion or bothered with grooming himself, and he wouldn't have waited as long as he had before making his move. If his motivation was to avenge his mother's death he'd have been plotting his revenge from the moment he had his awakening as a child, and not once is it insinuated throughout the game, novels, or manga, that revenge was his motivation.

His drive to obtain Sparda's power and become like Sparda was because he wanted to protect his loved ones - seeing as Dante is excluded from 'loved' ones and the rest of his family is dead, it could only mean that Vergil was in the same pickle as Sparda had been. And let's face it, the boys live what they learn. As example (Zany and I chatted about this before) the second fight between Dante and Nero in DMC4 was basically a copy of the fight between Dante and Vergil. The only difference is that Dante had been there, done that, got the wound to prove it, and knew Nero's next move which is why he was able to dodge it and catch Rebellion, whereas when Dante was faced with that situation the first time, Vergil had run him through with Yamato.

Considering this, there is no reason why Vergil wouldn't have known what needed to be done when he found himself facing a similar situation as Sparda once had. Instead of waiting for his enemy to make the first move and abandoning his loved ones to go fend off Mundus, Vergil took initiative to prepare himself so that when his turn came, he would be there and be fully capable of protecting his loved ones. And yeah, I'm going there, his 'loved ones' was most likely Nero and Nero's mother. The girl ought to have been pregnant during the events of DMC3, or seeing as Vergil started working on his plan a year before, she might have given birth the same year as DMC3. To work it into canon. I still think they made a major screw up with the ages in DMC4, but that aside, the puzzle pieces fit.

As for why Nero was orphaned - it could be a number of reasons. His mother might have been killed, the Order could have kidnapped him, or, the theory I'm running with as the most plausible, she gave him up for adoption when Vergil didn't come back. Vergil was young and she had to be quite young as well, and what girl that young can really be brave enough to raise a baby all by herself? If you add the option that she might have been aware of who and what Vergil was, it would have doubled her fear and given her even more reason to give Nero away. If you go on the assumption that the Order has existed for a good long time, it might have been Vergil's backup plan that she go to Fortuna because the citizens were well protected by the Knights and it wouldn't seem suspicious if a sudden demon attack was launched upon the city (to target her and Nero) because the Order was accustomed to and efficient at fending off demon attacks.

That's all up for debate, but my point is that taking everything we know about Nero and don't know about Nero, and everything we know about Vergil and don't know about Vergil, and you tie up the lose ends on both sides including all the hints, and you take a look at the bigger picture, the only thing that DOES make sense is that Vergil is Nero's father.

Now that I've got that out of my system. Feel free to bring your own pokers ^_^
 

The crazy demon

Metal Gear Vindicare.
Good theory.

I cannot bring by poker because you have a royal flush(If the hightest value name is that) and i got a duo.

YOu did tied loose ends :D.
 

Dante's Stalker

"Outrun this!"
Premium
Supporter 2014
I haz teh logic answers! All bow down before meh and my ebil brilliance!!! :D

Thanks guys, but I'm pretty sure someone will come along and try find a way to debunk my theory. Which is welcomed with open arms! ;)
 

V

Oldschool DMC fan
I always thought Vergil did what he did:

a) For himself. He thinks he has a right to Sparda's power, like an inheritance. All that power just sitting there with no-one to weild it, and Vergil reckons he can. "I've come to retrieve my power. You can't handle it."/"Why do you refuse to gain power, the power of our father, Sparda?"

b) Because he wants to be like (or surpass) Sparda. Who wouldn't? You hear so much about a legend, say, but if you actually have the ability to be as good, if not better than the legend, who wouldn't try? "...Or the son who surpassed him?"/"No matter how hard you try, you're never gonna be like Father." (Dante seems to know what Vergil was up to. He knows him better than we do, after all).

c) To protect himself. This should probably be foremost on the list. Vergil's probably quite weak emotionally hiding behind a facade of strength. The fact he chases more strength could be due to greed, boredom or fear or disgust of weakness. His mother is dead so he no longer needs to protect her, and Dante he knows will awaken like he is eventually. My guess is he wants to be invincible so the same thing doesn't happen to him. When he says "...you can't protect anything, (let alone yourself)" he could be alluding to Dante's desire to fight demons and protect people - he HAD set up a business doing it - OR Vergil could be referring to something else, I guess, perhaps something personal.

d) To challenge himself. Vergil seems to want worthy opponents to fight, as if he's well aware that his power already exceeds that of most creatures including humans, and if he wants better he's going to have to go deeper for it. Perhaps he was after Mundus - he knew who Mundus was when he met him - but he certainly seemed intent on staying in the Underworld as it has more to offer him than the human world. If he did have a human 'loved one' besides Dante, he was extremely confident of his plan going off and jumping into the Underworld and leaving her behind like that and all.

I would say your theory could be fine Chloe, but what bothers me is that Vergil wanted to stay in the Underworld because he felt like he belonged there. If he had a loved one up there, that he was doing it all for, to protect, why give her up to hang around in Hell just because "this place was our father's home?" I always thought it was because Vergil no longer identified with humans at all and he was better off living (or dying) in the Underworld, to his mind. If he didn't really feel that, why say it as such an emotional and final moment? Why not ask Dante to protect his loved one? Sure it's not in Vergil's character to return to the human world in defeat, but love has a habit of making you care less about pride and more about a person, right?

I suppose you could indeed be right because the words "If I become a demon, so be it; I will endure the exile, anything to protect her" used later in reference to Nero and Yamato are pretty much the same sentiment. Perhaps he would have dropped down into Hell and stayed there until he found enough power or slew enough demons to ensure the safety of his family. If I knew Vergil actually had a family for sure, I'd imagine he would do probably do that - take on a Sparda role, a protector role, I mean. But while he's off wandering about in Hell surely he knows his family would be as in danger as ever? It's a big risk.

Just a feeling from the games - I personally think Vergil has tried to cast off all his human ties and he's doing it because he can, because he thinks he has the right, and because he wants to push himself - he wants to be the best. His superior attitutde seems to attest to that ("Am I being... defeated?" As if he thought it could never happen). I don't think he's externally driven by any fear as he never shows fear of anything. Certainly internally, by a subsconcious fear of being weak, suffering the same fate as his mother... to Vergil, weak = death.
 

BlueDevil

Super Penguin Number 2
Premium
I actually feel more partial to Chloe's explanation, because for the longest time, I've believed Nero to be Vergil's son as well (for damn good reasons, not just because), and her theory makes perfect sense to me.
 

Dante's Stalker

"Outrun this!"
Premium
Supporter 2014
@Lexy - true, it doesn't make sense that he'd want to remain in the Underworld if he had family to protect, but what if distancing himself from his family was the best thing he could do? From what I've gathered, Sparda had known his sons during their young lives as he had 'trained' them, but he couldn't have filled a solid role in their lives because neither of his sons see him as their 'father', so I got the impression that Sparda had put his duty to protect mankind and slay demons above his role as a father, maybe not because he wanted to but because he had no choice in the matter (like, you make your bed you gotta sleep in it, type of scenario). So, maybe Vergil thought his family would be safer if he distanced himself from them and broke off any connection they have to him. Like protecting them from a distance in a discreet way? I mean, Nero didn't have the same issue that Dante and Vergil had, because Sparda's blood was so strong in them that they carried his scent. None of the demons in DMC4 accused Nero of being 'a treacherous relative of the tyrant Sparda' because he didn't carry Sparda's scent, it had become diluted possibly because his DNA was more human than demonic, or maybe Vergil was smart enough to know how to mask the scent for Nero...somehow...I dunno, that last one seems a bit out there. But you know what I mean. Sparda's blood had watered down in Nero because Nero had a half-human father and probably a human mother, whereas Sparda had been a full demon in a human body.

I mean, I can't say for sure why Vergil would choose to reside in the Underworld, but the only thing I can think of that would justify his decision is that it was his attempt to destroy all links between himself and his family to keep them safe.
 

BlueDevil

Super Penguin Number 2
Premium
I like the way you're describing Vergil. I've always liked the idea of Vergil possibly being an extremely noble, good guy type.
 

Meg

Well-known Member
Moderator
^ I always thought of Vergil as more of an anti hero than a villain. And in the intro/background info screen when installing DMC4 it says that Nelo more noble than other demons.
 

Freddy777

Heavens declare His Glory
Hey Chloe Ryder, your theory is very similar to what I have been proposing in the "how to the bring vergil back" thread in the DMC 5 forum.

Glad to see I am not the only one out there that feels this way about Vergil.
 

Zany Blac

Well-known Member
Read your theory and i have Bowed 2 Ur Ebil Genius!

But there is something you kinda forgot when you where writing this bro.

Yesh! I am poking ur balloon with a pin :p

It has recently become obvious(To me anyway) that Vergil is an Anakin Skywalker rip off albeit with a twist, thus the badassery and all.

That makes nelo angelo darth vader... of sorts with mundus as Sidious/Palpatine.

In the star wars triology sequel Anakin lost his arm right?

Vergils 'Arm' yamato was 'broken'

Luke Skywalker also lost his arm, his right arm fighting vader.

Capcom were'nt that stupid, they cudnt rip the entire star wars story.

Wait!

They are that stupid but... back on topic.

Anakins descent into evil started with his mothers loss... Vergil's too

At some point Vergil found his padme i believe. and we had Nero.

But if your theory is correct then we wud neva have our Vader which in this case is Nelo Angelo because vergil was good all along just didnt want to show it because he was scared someone would right fluff stories about him(Alot of good thats done :)... swing and a miss Vergil)

Given Anakin became vader without donning the iconic armor but so did vergil, seeing that alternate costume from DMC 3 again almost made me cry from not linking the two together (Corrupt Vergil).

So if vergil was fighting for his loved ones and all, he could still become the tragic figure vader was and he wud get his redemption dying in neros arms.

Darn it... i jus gave away DMC 5's plot.

Oh Well...

All i'm tyrna say is... perhaps your right, perhaps Vergil is doing another sparda and trying to protect his loved ones, But if star wars is anything to go by, we are going to be treated to the Return of the jedi with a very conceivable twist. It just links together and was brought about by my conviction that capcom is not very smart when it comes to story telling.

And thats one helluvan understatement.

Or I Cud be wrong and i owe u a sammich ;)

Cannot wait for TGS!
 

moseslmpg

Well-known Member
But Vader was total evil, he gave in totally. Vergil didn't become a willing servant of Mundus. So there's that.

But those similarities are interesting. Add that to the Yoda on Dante's wall, and George Lucas has himself a lawsuit :p
 

Zany Blac

Well-known Member
Come to think of it he kinda was but he was still porttrayed as a tragic figure.

The Killing of the young Jedi kinda lowers his score in the sympathy area.

Yoda on Dantes wall????

Where!? Where!?

:O
 

aoshi

Well-known Member
Wow, More than 5 years and still vergil seems to be a mystery. Damn capcom, you have yourself a winner.

I think vergil is as non-linear as dante and so was sparda.Capcom portrayed sparda as a dark knight who fought demons. But he was a demon himself. Which kinda questions his betrayal to demon origins?I am not questioning it but is only a logical perspective. Which can be seen in dante being a rebel for reasons that don't make logical sense.

Devil may cry 3 soundtrack quote:
"Useless cause is breaking your back"

I think vergil is a non-linear character who made interesting choices as dante or sparda but not sure why did capcom kill him.
 

Darth Angelo

Tuck-yet-chi-say-denie trieve trick-dis-nie
aoshi;278681 said:
Wow, More than 5 years and still vergil seems to be a mystery. Damn capcom, you have yourself a winner.

I think vergil is as non-linear as dante and so was sparda.Capcom portrayed sparda as a dark knight who fought demons. But he was a demon himself. Which kinda questions his betrayal to demon origins?I am not questioning it but is only a logical perspective. Which can be seen in dante being a rebel for reasons that don't make logical sense.

Devil may cry 3 soundtrack quote:
"Useless cause is breaking your back"

I think vergil is a non-linear character who made interesting choices as dante or sparda but not sure why did capcom kill him.

Because it was the first game and Vergil as he came to be known didn't exist yet. If 3 was made before 1 they wouldn't dream of killing Vergil off.
 

Zato-OW

King
Well going by the Manga,DMC4 Novel and DMC3. It seems Vergil wanted to be known as Sparda was(power wise), he said to Sanctus that humans seen Sparda as a God and that he had no issue with that. Vergil then says "When I surpass him then what would that make me?" This most likely means he just wants to surpass his father in power but at the same time using the whole "gaining power" issue as a way for him to justify his existence since he felt that his human side weakened him.

At the end of DMC3 you can start to get the filling Dante knew what Vergil was planning. He says to Vergil "No matter how hard you try, your never going to be like father." This angered Vergil and it angered him for a reason. Vergil knew that the demon world would stay open if both amulets combined. He also knew he would have the power of Sparda. Knowing Vergil from the information that was given, he was most likely planning on destroying the Devils World. Either that or just using Sparda's power to challenge the strongest demons for his own amusement.

We know for a fact that Vergil had no plans in destroying or ruling the Human World. If you pay attention to every scene in DMC3 with Vergil and Arkham together, you will see that Arkham is constantly going off about destroying the Human World and ruling over it. If you notice Vergil's face expressions then you will see he was starting to become very annoyed. You can also see his betrayal on Arkham coming sooner or later.

Vergil is neither good or bad...well hes more bad then good that's for sure. I would say hes in the grey area.

Your theory is good at parts but not so good at others. If Vergil had a family then he would have been smart enough to know that his father sealed the underworld for a reason. If Sparda had the power to defeat Mundus then why didn't he just take over and rule the underworld his self after Mundus fell? It's because it wouldn't have work in his favor. He was seen as a traitor and was hated by almost all demons. He can't fight billions upon billions of demons on his own even with Sparda's power.

I think Vergil's main goal was pretty simple. Power and more of it to make his life in his eyes seem meaningful. He was selfish knowing that alot of people would die by fusing both amulets and opening the underworld releasing hell upon earth. He knew why his father sealed the world and he didn't care. I think remember at the end of one of the DMC3 mangas that there was a demon speaking to Vergil and warning him. He warned him about entering the demon world and that he would never return.
 

cheezMcNASTY

Entertain me.
Premium
excellent theory. i've never given it much thought, but that sounds very plausible. have some rep. :)

moseslmpg;272207 said:
But Vader was total evil, he gave in totally. Vergil didn't become a willing servant of Mundus. So there's that.

But those similarities are interesting. Add that to the Yoda on Dante's wall, and George Lucas has himself a lawsuit :p

that doesn't make a lick of sense. she invested quite a bit of time organizing her thoughts and typing them into that mountainous first post post hoping for feedback, i think the least you could do is give her a serious reply. i mean honestly, that wasn't even funny. if you're going to make a nonsensical reply without adding anything useful at least entertain those of us who are using our brains to form comprehensive sentences.
 
Top Bottom