I'd only do it if the controls were nothing less than perfect.
No, you know what? I'm sorry, I know Red Steel 2 already had perfect "VR" first person DMC-style control, but I don't think it would sit well with the fans, no matter how well it was executed.
----
Therefore, I recommend that this VR game would be more like Telltale's Batman. Or just straight up copy VR Batman instead.
I think more people would be happier that way.