Excuse me, but which part of DMC4 Dante is fat? He does have broad shoulders and wider jawline than before, but otherwise he looks quite thin.http://www.unseen64.net/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/devil-may-cry-4-dante-e3-2005.jpg
That, from my point of view, will forever and always be the best-looking Dante. Way better than the DMC4 "fat alcoholic" look we got in the end, anyway.
I've seen fans (mostly female) laugh and call him fat, and it actually kinda bothers me, first because it's another example of double standard, and second having more pronounced muscles (like someone who lives the life of a sword wielding demon hunter should) doesn't make one fat.