Well I don't have that kind of hope or faith in PLATINUM GAMES.
Kamiya in a recent interview even stated that he was able to make the games he made at Capcom and Clover Studios because of the environment he was in or the environment Capcom made. He no longer works at Capcom and only a handful of people from Capcom or Team Little Devils work at PG right now and with the fact that people are leaving PG and getting new workers the environment that Kamiya made DMC1 under is not at PG or completely there. Its not just one person but an entire team effort and you have all sorts of people with different roles an they help mold and shape the game in various ways. DMC1 (and its atmosphere) was made by a strictly Resident Evil team who is still at Capcom mostly. The same guy who did the art for DMC1 Makoto whatever his name is doesn't work for PG either (I'm not sure if he still works for Capcom). In fact more people from the DMC4 team works at PG than members from TLD (Team Little Devils) One of the writers for DMC1 is dead and Kamiya has shown what he is capable of on his own (Okami, Bayonetta, Viewtiful Joe, and Wonderful 101), all light hearted cartooney action fun (yes even Bayonetta) with lots of sex jokes (although Okami had a pretty good story with nice usage of symbolism and mythology).
@1:15 Oh the irony!!
Barely anyone from TLD is still with PG so if Kamiya does makes DMC5 with Capcom's say-so the best chance of recreating the DMC1 feel is if he actually works with Capcom and get some of the old crew. Otherwise DMC5 or any DMC game from PG would be your standard Platinum Games' game (over the top with mass explosive action, QTEs, vulgarity up the wazoo and sex jokes....lots and lots of sex jokes or innuendos in MGR/W101/Okami/VJ case....lets not forget stereotypes and lets not forget the gore and violence). It'll still be a great game that might get panned by critics and reviewers (some of which might be upset their not getting DmC2 but instead a most likely polar opposite of what they liked about DmC). I'm not saying this is a bad thing. I'll prefer a DMC PG game any day over DmC2 or anything NT related.