I don't know, I can see someone giving Alan Wake a 9/10 despite the awful "final boss fight" (can it even be called that?), I just think that bosses are too essential for a game like this, precision and a story in a story-driven reboot should also have a lot more weight.
But yeah, reviews are more for a general audience than to the dedicated crowd of that genre, so I shouldn't expect more than an overview for people on the fence about buying the game. Around here everyone knows exactly what they're getting out of it so we all know if we want the game.