Sources aren't the end all be all of information, sometimes just using that bit of common sense makes all the difference especially helpful is knowing what fanbases react to and what they don't.
Tomb Raider was well received? I've heard it's a mixed bag of reactions to be honest, some like it and some don't. I know several old Tomb Raider fans who have reactions ranging from finding the game to be boring to Other M levels of insulting.
Having played a bit of it myself? I find it somewhere inbetween.
You're right, not all sources are correct or even believable, but at least it provides us with some info that is not solely based on one man's perception, view or opinion about something. Speaking on behalf of a whole fanbase is what I would call an unreliable source.
Enough of that though, it's a closed chapter now.
I guess it is like that in general then, that the reception of reboots is a mixed bag of emotions and opinions from the fanbases. Like with DmC, the louder crowd is indeed the nay-sayers, but it's generally like that, however, I've met alot of positive yay-sayers about DmC in this forum which seems to outweigh the nay-sayers. I guess they moved elsewhere, not being able to accept that there are people who actually like DmC, but that's up to them.
As a fan of storytelling in games, I thought Tomb Raider was excellent in that department. However, I do miss the dual-wielding gunslinger vixen we know from previous games. I hope she will be more like that in the sequal, should one be made.
Anyways, back to Megaman. Though I am no fan of first-person shooters, I thought the artstyle and the fast-paced action, not to mention the darker and grittier feel of this cancelled reboot was simply perfect! Megaman X and Megaman Zero are both series with a rather darker tone of storyline, compared to the original Megaman series and the newer games like Battle Network and ZX. The potential for a darker, more serious and mature series is there. And I would have loved to have seen it. Oh, if only they had a concept art or SOMETHING which showed Zero's new design...