A little extreme don't you think, well whatever suits you I guess. Anyway, I though Nocturne was a very good game as well and Digital Devil Saga was just as good. But one RPG that especially caught my attention was the Wild Arms series. Not a very famous series a admit, but it was very good none the less. The first and second were for the PS and 3, 4 and a remix of the first are for the PS2. My overall favorite has to be the second with its interesting story, cool charcters (especially a very awsome character known as Knightblazer) and really good combat system. I have kept that game ever since I bought it and still pop it in every once in a while.